www.laurahird.com
THE NEW REVIEW

The Mars Volta Experience
The band’s official website


The Mars Volta Live
Mathew West's review of the band's Barrowlands 11/3/05 concert


The Comatorium 3.0
Theory and Nardo’s The Mars Volta website


The Mars Volta Discography
Discography for the band on the Gold Standard Labs website


The Mars Volta Audio and Video Clips
Audio and video clips of the band on the MTV website


‘Frances the Mute’ Review Extracts
Review extracts for the album on the Metacritic website


‘Frances the Mute’ Review
Justin Cober-Lake and Adrien Begrand review the album on the Pop Matters website


‘Frances the Mute’ Review
Eric Greenwood reviews the album on the Pop Matters website


‘The Mars Volta: Rocking to a Different Beat’
Rasmi Gamble reviews the album on the Pendulum Online website


‘The Mars Volta Celebrates it’s Non-Conformity’
Patrick Berkery reviews the album on the Indystar website


The Mars Volta Live at Brixton Academy, London on 13/3/05
Karen Piper reviews the band’s gig on the Stereo Effect website


‘Frances the Mute’ Sound Clips
Sound clips from the album on the CD Universe website


‘Frances the Mute’ Review
Sam Ubl reviews the album on the Pitchfork Media website


Watch ‘The Widow’ Video
Watch the video on the NME website


‘Frances the Mute’ Review
Brian Gearing reviews the album on the Glide Magazine website


‘De-Loused in the Comatorium’ Review
Brent DiCrescenzo reviews the album on the Pitchfork Media website


‘Frances the Mute’ Review
Kevin Krieger reviews the album on the Times Leader website


‘Frances the Mute’ Review
Tom MacDonald reviews the album on the Scan Music website


Transient Jet Lag
The official Mars Volta fan community website


The Mars Volta Interview
Karen Piper interviews the band on the Steroe Effect website


‘My Favorite Martian: An Interview with Jon Theodore of The Mars Volta’
Gail Worley interviews the band’s drummer on the Ink 19 website


Can you really have too much of a good thing? The Mars Volta’s debut ‘De-loused In The Comatorium’ was such a blood red feast, this listener’s digestive juices were still busy breaking the thing down when word came of a follow up. And whaddya know – the scope, scale, complexity and ambition of ‘Frances The Mute,’ recorded in NY, LA, Puerto Rico and Australia, make its predecessor seem almost straightforward. For starters, the opening ‘Cygnus…Vismund Cygnus’ is a furnace of late Zeppelin dynamics crossed with Latin rhythm, unbelievable playing and ferocious kinetic energy. Cedric Bixler Zavala spits castrato non-sequiturs over Omar A Rodriguez-Lopez’s serpentine licks, with a 70s soul string arrangement thrown in for good measure. The single (ha!)‘The Widow’, is probably the closest thing to an orthodox rock tune on here, but even that’s so convoluted with mariachi metal shapes one suspects the musicians (the extended cast includes Lenny Castro on percussion as well as Flea on trumpet and John Frusciante on guitar) required a map just to play the thing through once, never mind arrange and mix it.

Elsewhere, ‘L’ Via L’ Viaquez’ slips from hard rock to slinky samba then back to cracked blaxploitation and dissonant skronk, concluding with an electric flamenco flourish. It’s as if ‘Sketches Of Spain’ had been revived by one of Miles’s later fusion bands with one eye on stadium rock and the other on ‘Trout Mask Replica.’ As for the closing 24-minute ‘Cassandra Geminni’, with its Coltrane ascensions, it would take about a month to properly digest and describe its labyrinthine cells and chambers.

So there’s no middle ground. If you buy into this, you’re just gonna have to indulge The Mars Volta their sprawling ambitions. Yes, entire passages of ambient atmospheres and exercises in electronic sound manipulation could’ve been edited from the mix without incurring much damage, but those Roger Dean slurs miss the point. The Storm Thorgerson artwork, the titles, the way the tracks are broken up into movements, plus the overarching theme (‘Frances…’ is based on a notebook found by deceased MV FX man Jeremy Ward, detailing the anonymous diarist’s search for his birth parents) – these are merely cosmetic. The Mars Volta are as plugged into the dark heart of gothic Mexican duende and bordertown punk as they are King Crimson and ‘Physical Graffiti.’ Cedric’s lyrics are not meditations on hobgoblins and fairies so much as apparitional bad trips through vistas of tombstone teeth, snake eyes, black lungs, crawling bugs and crucifixes.

As I write, message boards are buzzing with debate over this album, with even faithful followers struggling to get their chops around its ungainly bulk. Understandably enough, some folk still hanker after ‘At The Drive-In’s’ furious tautologies. I know I do. But give it time. This is a long day’s journey across topographies populated with grinning skeletons bedecked in feathers and top hats. ‘Frances The Mute’ bristles with hallucinatory imaginative powers, and, in parts, a sort of genius.

Later for that three-minute garage rock record.


© Peter Murphy
Reproduced with permission



One of Ireland’s foremost music and pop culture writers, Peter Murphy (b. 1968, Enniscorthy, Co. Wexford) got a taste for journalism at the age of 17 when he won first place in an EU sponsored competition for young essayists. After ten days of being wined, dined and chauffeured around Europe on someone else’s tab, the only proviso being that he file a report at the end of it, he figured this was the way to live. But first, he had to get the rock ‘n’ roll bug out of his system, and spent most of the next decade playing drums with a succession of bands. He quit music to become a journalist in 1996, quickly establishing himself as a senior contributor to Hot Press. Since then he has written over 30 cover stories for the magazine, accumulating a portfolio of interviews that includes Lou Reed, Patti Smith, Nick Cave, Willie Nelson, Radiohead, Public Enemy, Shane MacGowan, George Clinton, Sonic Youth, Television, Henry Rollins, PJ Harvey, Richard Hell, David Johansen, Warren Zevon, Wim Wenders, Iain Banks, Will Self, William Gibson, Billy Bob Thornton, FW De Klerk and many others. His work has also appeared in the Bloodaxe Books anthology Dublines, the Sunday Independent (Ireland) plus international publications such as Rolling Stone (Australia) and Request (US). Miscellaneous assignments include writing the programme notes for jazz legend Miles Davis’ art exhibition hosted by the Davis Gallery in Dublin (2000), collaborations with cult author JT LeRoy for the American magazine Razor (2002), and co-producing Revelations, a two-hour radio documentary about The Frames (2003). He is frequently employed as a rent-a-mouth by the BBC and Irish national radio and television, is a contributor to the online archive Rocksbackpages.com and more recently gave a talk entitled Nocturnal Emissions at the ReJoyce symposium in the National College of Ireland, tracing the influence of James Joyce’s writings on Irish music. He has also been invited to contribute an essay to the liner notes of the 2004 remastered edition of Harry Smith’s Anthology Of American Folk Music, and is currently writing his first novel.


In Association with Amazon.co.uk


© 2005 Laura Hird All rights reserved.




FRANCES THE MUTE
The Mars Volta

(Island 2005)

By Peter Murphy

If you would be interested in reviewing films/books for the site, contact me here
REVIEW
INDEX
Music Review
About Me
Artists
Books & Stuff
Competition
Contact Me
Diary
Events
FAQ's
Film Profiles
Film Reviews
Frank's Page
Genre Bending
Hand Picked Lit Links
Heroes
Index
Links
Lit Mag Central
The New Review
New Stuff
Projects
Publications
Punk @ laurahird.com
Recipes
Samples
Sarah’s Ancestors
Save Our Short Story
Site Map
Showcase


RELATED ITEMS


Order The Mars Volta’s ‘De-Loused in the Comatorium’

Order The Mars Volta’s ‘The Widow’ [Single]

Order Omar A. Rodriguez-Lopez’s ‘A Manual Dexterity V.1’

Order The Mars Volta’s ‘Tremulant’ EP

Order the Free Moral Agents’ ‘Everybody’s Favourite Weapon’

Order the Mars Volta’s ‘Televators’ [10” Vinyl Single]

Order ‘The String Quartet Tribute to The Mars Volta’

Order The Mars Volta’s ‘Inertiatic Esp’ [Single]