| www.laurahird.com |
| THE NEW REVIEW |
|
Fay Weldon reviews the novel on the Guardian Unlimited website
|
|
About Me Artists Books & Stuff Competition Contact Me Diary Events FAQ's Film Profiles Film Reviews Frank's Page Genre Bending Hand Picked Lit Links Heroes Index Links Lit Mag Central The New Review New Stuff Projects Publications Punk @ laurahird.com Recipes Samples Sarah’s Ancestors Save Our Short Story Site Map Showcase Tynie Talk RELATED ITEMS![]() Order Mantel’s ‘Giving Up the Ghost’ Order Mantel’s ‘A Place of Greater Safety’ Order Mantel’s ‘An Experiment in Love’ Order Mantel’s ‘Vacant Possession’ Order Mantel’s ‘Eight Months on Ghazzah Street’ Order Mantel’s ‘Every Day is Mother’s Day’ Order Mantel’s ‘Fludd’ Order Mantel’s ‘A Change of Climate’ Order Mantel’s ‘The Giant, O’Brien’ Order Mantel’s ‘Learning to Talk’
|
|
Alison is a medium, travelling the London orbital from psychic Fair to psychic Fair in the company of her newly acquired prosaic assistant, Colette. The seedier side of psychics and mediums is exposed here, the little frauds and tricks which con the clients – not that they don’t deserve to be conned: their howling hunger for trivial messages from the dead (kitchen units and such ) and their gloating appetite for the melodrama of mediumship after the death of Princess Diana, is nauseating. But among the tawdry fakirs (one whose grandmother was psychic to the Tsars before the family came down in the world and became psychics to the Stars), Alison is a little different. She is completely honest and believes in her gift. Her head is filled with a cacophony of voices of the dead, and she is accompanied everywhere by a spirit called Morris, a vile and coarse little ghost who interferes with women when he can and will give her no peace. Colette the assistant has no real belief in Alison’s powers (she’s a dampener is Colette, completely without imagination or dreams) but is well able to market Alison and undertake to write a book of her experiences. It is the taping of interviews with Alison which allows her secrets to come out and show that the line between psychic powers and personal psychodrama is blurred. Mantel is a favourite author of mine, an intelligent writer with a devastating wit and talent for exposing the ordinary as something else entirely. Alison is a fine creation – a large fat woman in peach, stoically enduring torment at the hands of ‘the Fiends’, the voices which haunt her. “The afterlife is just like Aldershot’”she maintains, and this line is funny in context, less funny as the novel progresses, because Aldershot is where Alison grew up, or was dragged up, by her prostitute mother. This is where she acquired the dreadful Morris, whom Alison taunts with never having been given a Christian burial when he provokes her sufficiently. There is considerable aggression between Morris and Alison – she gets tumbled out of bed in the middle of the night by him, threatened and terrorised, often with an uncomfortable sexual overtone. In the course of taping for Colette’s book, amid the hilarity of the medium’s meetings and Alison’s .humorous observations
(“There’s a certain 1950s air about the dead…because they’re clean and respectable…as if they came before white nylon shirts and indoor sanitation…certainly before sexual intercourse.”) The appalling truth about Alison’s past emerges - the lesson she was taught, the scars on her legs, the operation which took her will out of her and put theirs in instead. The voices she hears are the voices of these teachers, her mother’s clients, and the extremes to which Alison was driven to by them when still a child. So the ghost story may not after all be a ghost story at all – maybe this is a story about repression of memory and a very different kind of haunting from the traditional kind. However you wish to interpret it, the book is a wildly hilarious and painfully sad revelation of a woman’s life. There are no graphics here – Alison’s ’s mother may hire her out to men, but Alison only recalls being told always to say she was sixteen “which is confusing when you’re only about 10’” and lets the reader work out what is going on. The novel is rich with characters – the psychics and their preferred modes of communication and dress; the ghastly spirits who haunt Alison, every bit as real as the living, and certainly more powerful; the clients who must be protected from the things Alison knows, but from whose biographies she herself has no protection. As always with Mantel, the dialogue crackles with wit and shrewd observation. The collapse of Colette’s marriage, shown through dialogue, is a perfect gem, both amusing and sad and outrageous. The chat between the psychics is riotous. But it is Alison herself, with her edged fragments of memory of bits of waste ground and glimpse of savage violence, her compassion and her confusion, her wit and her suffering, who makes this novel a great one. Reproduced with permission Marion Arnott lives in Paisley, Scotland. She was winner of the Phillip Good Memorial Prize For Women's Fiction 1998, CWA Short Dagger 2001 and shortlisted for CWA Short Dagger 2002. Work has appeared in Scottish Child, West Coast, Solander Magazine, Peninsula , QWF, Hayakawa Mystery Magazine (Japan), Books Ireland, Northwords, Chapman, Crimewave, and Datlow and Winding's Year's Best Fantasy and Horror volume 15. Her short story collection 'Sleepwalkers,' was published in August, 2003 by Elastic Press. To visit Marion's Showcase on this website, click here
|
| BEYOND BLACK Hilary Mantel (Harper Perennial 2005) Reviewed by: Marion Arnott |
| If you would be interested in reviewing films/books for the site, contact me here |
| Book Review |