www.laurahird.com
THE NEW REVIEW
This is England
The film’s official website


This is England - Trailer
Trailer for the film on the YouTube website


This is England Review
Review on the BBC Films website


This is England Review
Review on the Guardian Unlimited website


This is England Review
Review on the Times Online website


Shane Meadows
The director’s official website


An 18 for This Is England? This is An Outrage
Article and comments on the Guardian Unlimited website


New Boots and Rants
Review on the BFI website


Stephen Graham Interview
Interview with the actor on the Indie London website


Shane Meadows Interview
Interview with the director on the Indie London website


Shane Meadows Interview
Watch interview with the director on the BBC Films website


Racism and Rights of Passage
Interview with Stephen Graham on the Eye for Film website


I Was a Skinhead Myself in 1983
Interview with Shane Meadows on the Guardian Unlimited website


Shane Meadows Interview
Interview with the director on the Time Out website


The opening montage of Roland Rat, Rubik’s cube, the Falklands war, TV AM aerobics (ace!) and the miners Strike is an apt introduction to Shane Meadows most personal work so far . In ‘This is England‘, he takes a look at his own eighties childhood through the experiences of Sean, a 12 year old who has just lost his dad in the Falklands. Sean and his mum (a wonderful Deirdre Barlow style concoction from Jo Hartley) are struggling through it. Each holding on to the other and not much else.

Set in a grim but naive Midlands, the film has much more in common with the realist drama of ‘Scully’ or ‘Boys from the Blackstuff’ than ‘The full Monty’ or any of Guy Ritchie’s nonsense.

By teaming up with a gang of sympathetic older skinheads led by nice guy Woody, Sean finds somewhere to belong. But NF fuckup Combo (just out of prison and an ABSO before his time) quickly turns up to rip the tight little group apart. If Sean needs a father figure, unfortunately Combo is in the right place at the right time.

Predictably, race and identity are the focus as he gathers strength from a bunch of losers desperate for anything to believe in. It’s the timeless story of angry young men raging against the world. And at heart this is a simple coming of age drama with the nihilism of the early Thatcher years as it’ s backdrop. Her majesties’ bizarre eulogies to Queen and country burble from every radio and TV throughout, and in the context they’re as meaningless and black hearted as ever.

But Meadows has really managed to make a worthwhile feel good film. A social commentary that’s warm spirited and funny without being cloying. Alan Bleasdale would be proud. The characterisation is always allowed to carry the plot and at times it’s little short of wonderful.

The supporting cast are all good and are allowed space to develop, but Thomas Turgood as Sean and Steven Graham (Combo) are both outstanding. Combo is no one dimensional Berkhoff parody of the English racist. He’s an explosion of fear, resentment, frailty and anger who gets just about (but not quite) as much sympathy as anything else. The bleak moment where Woody’s girlfriend Lol rejects him is almost unwatchable. Combo just doesn’t get it. He’s the one who will never, ever learn and Graham is so intense it’s painful to watch.

Meadows allows all of this to unfold through character, and he avoids the kind of easy sensationalism which could ruin the sheer power of the piece. Above all this film seems to appreciate that people who do, say and think bad things are still just people. The parallels with today are presumably no accident.

If you’ve been shaking your head at the media’ s hyped up nonsense over Big Brother, you’ll be glad that Meadows takes a much less hysterical stance. But that means the racism here is real and menacing, with the courage to kick the shit out of it’s convictions.

There is one brutally violent scene which plays out just as it should. A blank, final admission of defeat. It’s the crux of the film and Combo is terrifying but at the same time pitiful. For him at least, everything really is lost. It’s a remarkable moment, and when they’re giving awards out, Graham should be near the top of the list.

Nothing’s perfect, though, and occasionally Meadows allows things to drift towards sentimentality. As a whole the film avoids it, although the inclusion of ‘Please, Please, Please Let Me Get What I Want’ in the final scenes probably oversteps the mark. But for a film about a 12 year old who’s dad has just died, it’s excusable.

A quick mention has to go to the soundtrack, which mixes eighties pop (The Specials, Soft Cell etc.) and some fantastic roots reggae. Toots and the Maytals storming ‘Louie Louie’ manages to make an appearance, along with Pressure Drop, Lee Perry and a good few others. And because of the time and place, it doesn’t feel staged or as if it’s the usual ploy to sell the soundtrack CD. But buy it if you see it.

Maybe it’s something to do with being Scottish, but for as long as I can remember England has teetered on the edge of disaster. What with Littlejohn and Monbiot’s demented grappling over the white Cliffs of Dover, I’m still waiting for them to crumble slowly into the channel while a bloke with a clipboard whistles ‘Rule Britannia‘. But it hasn’t happened yet and you know it probably never will. Because away from all the shite and the shouting, the foaming mouths and the whining for warm beer, England quietly manages to produce great work like this. Film of the year so far.


© Stuart Blackwood
Reproduced with permission



Stuart Blackwood is 30 (odd), was born in Newarthill and lives in Glasgow. He supports Motherwell FC, has an MA in Economics and Philosophy and likes William Bell (the singer), Bukowski & Fante, Eric Arthur Blair, Negativeland, Eric Hobsbawm, politics, philosophy and ambiguity. He dislikes Alan Bloom and Francis Fukuyama, U2, categorization and Violence.




In Association with Amazon.co.uk


© 2007 Laura Hird All rights reserved.




THIS IS ENGLAND
Dir: Shane Meadows (2007)

Reviewed by Stuart Blackwood
If you are interested in reviewing films/books for the site, contact me here
REVIEW
INDEX
Film Review
About Me
Artists
Best Tunes
Books & Stuff
Competition
Contact Me
Diary
Events
FAQ's
Film Profiles
Film Reviews
Frank's Page
Genre Bending
Hand Picked Lit Links
Heroes
Index
Links
Lit Mag Central
The New Review
New Stuff
Projects
Publications
Punk @ laurahird.com
Recipes
Samples
Sarah’s Ancestors
Save Our Short Story
Site Map
Showcase


RELATED ITEMS


Order Meadows‘ ‘A Room for Romeo Brass‘

Order Meadows‘ ‘Twenty Four Seven‘

Order Meadows‘ ‘Dead Man‘s Shoes‘

Order Meadows‘ ‘Once Upon a Time in the Midlands‘