www.laurahird.com
THE NEW REVIEW
Abbas Kiarostami Close-Up
Study of the director on the Strictly Film School website


‘Human Beings and Their Problems are the Most Important Raw Material for Any Film’
David Walsh interviews Abbas Kiarostami on the World Socialist website


Abbas Kiarostami Profile
Mehrnaz Saeed-Vafa’s profile of the director on the Senses of Cinema website


Abbas Kiarostami Profile
Profile of the director on the Iranian Movies website


Abbas Kiarostami Profile
Profile of the director on the History of Cinema website


Retrospectives
Extracts from Hushang Golmakani’s interview with the director on the Pardo website


‘Fill in the Blanks’
Jonathan Rosenbaum’s Chicago Reader review of Kiarostami’s ‘Taste of Cherry’


‘The Iranian Who Won the World’s Attention’
Godfrey Cheshire’s article on Kiarostami on The Iranian website


‘Abbas Kiarostami’ Review
Mehrnaz Saeed-Vafa and Jonathan Rosenbaum’s review of the film about Kiarostami on the University of Illinois website


‘The Compassionate Gaze’
David Walsh reports on Abbas Kiarostami’s press conference at the 2000 San Francisco International Film Festival


‘Abbas Kiarostami Controversy at the 40th NYFF’
Celeste Bohlen’s article on the Human Rights Watch website


Abbas Kiarostami Biography and Filmography
Biography and filmography of the director on the official Cannes Film Festival website


‘People Watching’
Lee Marshall’s Guardian Unlimited article on Kiarostami’s stage debut, ‘Ta'ziyeh’


Abbas Kiarostami Profile
Profile of the director on the BFI website


‘After the Rain’
Read Kiarostami’s short story on the Zoetrope website


‘In Dialogue with Kiarostami’
Ali Akbar Mahdi interview the director on The Iranian website


‘Films Without Borders’
Scott Foundas’s Indiewire interview with the director


Abbas Kiarostami Profile
Profile of the director on the Iran Chamber website


Meeting Abbas Kiarostami
Peter Rist’s Off Screen interview with the director


‘Kiarostami: The Man with the Digital Camera’
Mahmood Khoshchereh’s Net Iran article on the director


‘Abbas Kiarostami: The Art of Living’ Review
Review on the Artfifa website


‘Why Do You Make Films?’
UNESCO Courier interview with the director


The Stranger Interview with Abbas Kiarostami
Caveh Zahedi interviews the director on The Stranger website


‘Five Reflections on Abbas Kiarostami’s ‘Ten’
Rolando Caputo’s Senses of Cinema article on ‘Ten’


About Me
Artists
Books & Stuff
Competition
Contact Me
Diary
Events
FAQ's
Film Profiles
Film Reviews
Frank's Page
Genre Bending
Hand Picked Lit Links
Heroes
Index
Links
Lit Mag Central
New Stuff
Projects
Publications
Punk @ laurahird.com
Recipes
Samples
Sarah’s Ancestors
Save Our Short Story
Showcase
Site Map
Tynie Talk


RELATED DVD'S

Order Kiarostami’s ‘Close-up’ on dvd

Order Kiarostami’s ‘The Wind Will Carry Us’ on dvd

Order Moshen Makhmalbaf’s ‘Kandahar’ on dvd

Order Babak Payami’s ‘Secret Ballot’ on dvd

Order Jafar Panahi’s ‘The Circle’ on dvd

Order Marziyeh Meshkini’s ‘The Day I Became a Woman’ on dvd

Order Samira Makhmalbaf’s ‘Blackboards’ on dvd

Order Bahman Ghobadi’s ‘A Time for Drunken Horses’ on dvd

Order Bahman Ghobadi’s ‘Marooned in Iraz’ on dvd

Order Abderrahmane Sissako’s ‘Waiting for Happiness’ on dvd

Order Nuri Bilge Ceylan’s ‘Uzak’ on dvd

Order Pen-ek Ratanaruang’s ‘Last Life in the Universe’ on dvd

‘Ten’ is a simple but powerful look into the lives of ordinary Iranian women. Following a woman driver in Tehran and her passengers over ten journeys, the film presents a down-to-earth set of scenarios, with acting so naturalistic, ‘Ten’ often resembles reality TV.

The unnamed driver, played wonderfully by Mania Akbari, is a divorcee who has remarried. In the first journey, which begins with her son, Amin, getting into the car, we are plunged into conflict, as the young boy shouts at her, waves his hand, calls her an arsehole, and makes it very clear that he disapproves of her divorcing his father. Amin doesn’t like his stepfather, and wants to go and live with his father. He calls his mother selfish, and berates her for claiming his father was a drug addict. She tries to explain that in this “shit” country, women don’t have any rights, and she had to tell the court his father was an addict in order to get the divorce. She talks about how a person can only belong to themselves, and the need to love yourself before you can love another. This is a theme she will return to on other journeys. The son tries to cover his ears, shout her down, and threatens to throw his bag out the car window. If parents in the West think their kids don’t respect them, they should take a look at this film. In some respects, the viewer can’t help wondering if this young boy is just another male chauvinist in the making, egged on by his culture. But he’s not an unsympathetic character, and as the film goes on, we see how strong and opinionated his mother is with other people, even dishing out unsympathetic advice to a weeping woman. She can’t be the stay-at-home mother who’s always there for him. She’s not the type. He resents this, and thinks she’s a bad mother.

The drama is shot entirely from a digital camera on the dash board. No film crew are present. Sometimes the camera focuses solely on one person - the driver or her passenger. Other times it cuts back and forth so we see both. On the first journey, we never see the driver, only the boy. The actors are completely unselfconscious and natural. The viewer hence is like an eavesdropper, looking into other lives.

Later journeys follow the driver with her sister, then an old woman on her way to a mausoleum. This elderly woman hardly shuts up as she tells of how she has given up her possessions, gone on pilgrimages and goes to the mausoleum to pray three times a day. She talks about various saints and shows the driver her rosary.

On another journey, it’s night in Tehran. A prostitute has mistakenly got into the car, thinking the driver was a man. The driver won’t stop to let her out, and is brimming with curiosity, wanting to ask her about her work and life. “Pretend I’m a man,” she tells the giggling, sniggering girl. “I’m not working in that field yet,” the girl laughs. But the driver persists, asking her about her life, and why she does what she does. The girl claims to like her work. She points out that marriage too is an exchange that involves sex. “You’re the wholesalers. We’re the retailers,” she claims. This conversation is one of the most revealing in the entire film. We never see this girl’s face. What we do see is her figure from the back, through the windscreen, as she goes off to find another punter. She’s wearing a head scarf and is dressed modestly.

The son appears again in several sections of the film, and we see the changes in their relationship. He’s living with his father now. But it’s clear from their conversations in the car that there’s still some tension between mother and son. The two of them are able to joke more about his father getting a new wife. This wife, the driver thinks, will be obedient and submissive, always in the house cooking and cleaning.

A young woman from a previous journey is picked up again. She wears her headscarf tight. When she loosens it, we see her shaved head, and she finally takes the scarf off. As the driver points out, she looks even better with her head shaved. They talk about why she did it, and it’s one of the more moving segments of the film, with first-class acting, though it never seems like acting. Then the son is back for the last journey.

The ten sections appear as a countdown from 10 to 1. By the end, the driver seems to have reconciled herself with her son’s move to his father’s. If she hasn’t found complete peace of mind, she’s moved on from where she was. The viewer too has moved on, from vague stereotyped ideas about life in Iran and other Muslim countries to a clearer sense of the things different societies have in common. The driver’s plight, as a woman, is not so different from that of Western mothers who try to balance their different roles with a working life. Though her country gives her even fewer rights, her day-to-day life is not so different from a European’s. She’s smart and sophisticated, and the story might have been somewhat different if it had been told from the perspective of a poorer woman, with many children, living in a more isolated part of the country. Her self-help philosophies based on loving yourself are, if anything, more important to her than religion, which she doesn’t talk about much. She’s made compromises however. When questioned by the prostitute, it becomes clear that her new marriage is based on more practical considerations like friendship and companionship, rather than romantic illusions.

Director Abbas Kiarostami was voted the most important director of the 1990’s in a poll of US critics. What’s so refreshing about ‘Ten’ is the film’s intimacy, and its ability to draw the viewer into its world. The fixed camera shots, far from limiting the film, open it up on an emotional and psychological level. There are moments of humour, anger, and poignancy in ‘Ten.’ But the film also achieves something else - it shows what can be done with a film camera in a confined space, with a small cast and a low budget. It’s not necessary to spend millions on making a good film. Abbas Kiarostami’s engrossing film is ample evidence of that.

© Kara Kellar Bell
Reproduced with permission


Kara Kellar Bell is a film and media graduate from the West of Scotland, with a passion for European novels, French films, silent cinema, and Brazilian music (everything from Daniela Mercury and other pop stars through to bossa nova). As a writer, she likes to have room to move around creatively, so she’s not located in one genre. She writes realism and also stories of a more fantastic nature, usually grounded to some extent in the real world. She also takes delight in writing across the sexual spectrum, and as a bisexual, considers it important to remind people that things are not always black and white, either/or, in sexuality or in gender. She is currently completing her first novel. For a selection of Kara’s writing on the Showcase section of this site, click here or for a selection of Karen's reviews, click Review Index above




© 2004 Laura Hird All rights reserved.



TEN
(2002)
Dir: Abbas Kiarostami

Reviewed by: Kara Kellar Bell
If you would be interested in reviewing films/books for the site, please contact me here
REVIEW
INDEX
Film Review